Legal Comparison

DPDPA 2023 vs CCPA/CPRA

A detailed comparative analysis of India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act and California's Consumer Privacy Act for organisations operating across US-India markets.

Executive Summary

DPDPA and CCPA represent fundamentally different privacy philosophies. DPDPA follows the opt-in consent model prevalent in European-style legislation, requiring affirmative consent before data processing. CCPA adopts the American notice-and-choice model, permitting processing by default with consumer opt-out rights.

The most significant operational difference lies in the "sale of data" concept. CCPA creates specific obligations around data sale with its "Do Not Sell" mechanism, while DPDPA requires consent for all commercial use of personal data, rendering the sale distinction less relevant. Organisations must implement distinct compliance architectures for each jurisdiction.

DPDPA: Opt-In Model

Processing requires affirmative consent before collection. No processing without explicit permission. "Legitimate Uses" provide limited exceptions for employment, legal obligations, and public interest.

CCPA: Opt-Out Model

Processing permitted by default with notice. Consumers must actively opt-out of sale/sharing. Businesses bear burden of providing opt-out mechanisms and honouring preferences.

Legislative Framework

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Full NameDigital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023California Consumer Privacy Act (as amended by CPRA)
JurisdictionIndia (Federal law applicable nationwide)California, USA (State law with extraterritorial effect)
Effective DateFull enforcement: 13th May 2027CCPA: 1st January 2020; CPRA amendments: 1st January 2023
Regulatory AuthorityData Protection Board of IndiaCalifornia Privacy Protection Agency (CPPA)
Legal ModelConsent-centric (opt-in model)Notice and opt-out model

Scope & Applicability

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Covered EntitiesAll Data Fiduciaries processing digital personal dataBusinesses meeting revenue/data volume thresholds
Revenue ThresholdNone; applies to all entities processing personal dataAnnual gross revenue exceeding $25 million
Data Volume ThresholdNone specifiedBuy/sell/share data of 100,000+ consumers/households
Covered DataDigital personal data (excludes non-digital)Personal information (broader; includes inferences)
Employee DataCovered under employment Legitimate UseCovered; specific provisions for B2B and employee data

Consumer/Principal Rights

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Right to Know/AccessSection 11: Summary of personal data and processing activitiesRight to know categories and specific pieces of PI collected
Right to DeleteSection 13: Erasure upon consent withdrawal or purpose completionRight to delete PI with specified exceptions
Right to CorrectSection 12: Correction of inaccurate or incomplete dataRight to correct inaccurate PI (added by CPRA)
Right to PortabilityNot explicitly providedRight to receive PI in portable, machine-readable format
Right to Opt-Out of SaleNot applicable (consent required for all processing)Core right: "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information"
Right to Limit Sensitive Data UseStricter consent requirements for sensitive dataRight to limit use/disclosure of sensitive PI
Non-DiscriminationNot explicitly statedCannot discriminate against consumers exercising rights

Consent & Legal Basis

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Default ModelOpt-in: Affirmative consent required before processingOpt-out: Processing permitted unless consumer objects
Sale of DataRequires explicit consent; no concept of "sale" exemptionPermitted with opt-out right; "sale" broadly defined
Sharing for AdvertisingRequires specific consent for targeted advertisingCross-context behavioural advertising requires opt-out
Sensitive DataExplicit consent with additional safeguardsOpt-in consent or right to limit use
Children's DataVerifiable parental consent for all under 18Opt-in for under 16; parental consent for under 13

Business Obligations

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Privacy NoticeItemised notice with 8 mandatory elements before collectionNotice at collection; privacy policy with 10+ disclosures
Data Processing AgreementsRequired with Data Processors under Section 8(2)Service provider/contractor agreements required
Data Protection Impact AssessmentRequired for Significant Data FiduciariesRisk assessments required under CPRA for high-risk processing
Opt-Out MechanismsNot applicable (opt-in model)"Do Not Sell/Share" link required on homepage
Global Privacy ControlNot addressedMust honour browser-based opt-out signals

Penalties & Enforcement

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Maximum Administrative Penalty₹250 crore (~$30 million) per contravention$7,500 per intentional violation
Per-Violation PenaltyFixed maximum amounts in Schedule$2,500 (unintentional) to $7,500 (intentional) per violation
Penalty ScalingAggregate caps regardless of organisation sizePer-violation model can accumulate to massive amounts
Private Right of ActionNo private right of actionLimited to data breaches; statutory damages $100-$750 per consumer
Cure PeriodBoard may provide opportunity to remedyNo cure period under CPRA (removed from original CCPA)

Cross-Border Transfers

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Default PositionPermitted except to blacklisted countriesNo specific cross-border transfer restrictions
Transfer MechanismGovernment notification of restricted countriesContractual provisions; standard requirements for service providers
Data LocalisationMay be prescribed for certain categoriesNo data localisation requirements

Data Brokers & Sale

AspectDPDPA 2023 (India)CCPA/CPRA (California)
Data Broker DefinitionNo specific data broker provisionsBusiness that collects PI of consumers with whom it has no direct relationship
Registration RequirementConsent Manager registration for intermediariesData brokers must register with California AG
Sale DefinitionNo "sale" concept; all sharing requires consentSale = disclosure for monetary or valuable consideration
Delete SignalsNot applicableData brokers must honour delete signals (proposed)

Compliance Implications for US-India Operations

1. Consent Architecture: Organisations processing Indian residents' data must implement opt-in consent mechanisms regardless of their CCPA opt-out infrastructure. A unified consent management platform should support both models.

2. Website Requirements: The CCPA "Do Not Sell/Share" link is not required under DPDPA, but the DPDPA itemised privacy notice must be provided before or at the point of data collection.

3. Children's Data: DPDPA applies parental consent requirements to all individuals under 18, significantly broader than CCPA's under-16 threshold. Age verification mechanisms must account for this difference.

4. Data Subject Requests: Response procedures differ; organisations should establish jurisdiction-specific workflows while maintaining unified request intake systems.

Legal Disclaimer: This comparison is provided for educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. CCPA analysis incorporates CPRA amendments effective 1st January 2023. DPDPA analysis reflects DPDP Rules, 2025 notified 13th November 2025. Organisations should obtain jurisdiction-specific legal counsel.